Nickelback, a name that once went triple platinum in every middle-aged Mum’s Ford Fiesta back in the 2000s, is now a name that constantly arises when asked, “Which band is over hated?” Delivering tracks such as How You Remind Me, Savin’ Me, and If Today Was Your Last Day, that have stood the test of time, proves that the despise for Nickelback came from those that lacked joy and whimsy in their hearts. The rest of us, well, we got it. Returning to the rock scene after 4 years is sure to bring anticipation, but it also breeds the burning question of whether the band have served their purpose in modern music, or they have what it takes to become a legacy band and continue for years to come. TLDR; in the honest opinion of this critic, it’s the former.
Unfortunately, “Everything Under The Sun” barely makes it off the startling line with what can only be described as a missed mark. Opening track, Rattle The Cage and its eye-roll worthy monotony serve as nothing but a way to trick your attention into thinking that Nickelback still know how to deliver high energy, gritty songs. First tracks are supposed to set the tone and expectations for the entire record, and when there’s 12 songs at stake, starting at a very below-the-bar position doesn’t do well for anticipation. It sounds like they’re dipping into their heavier side, but it lacks the execution that was once there. While Nickelback have never been an astoundingly technical band, their best work came from whether the tracks had replayability and groove. Once upon a time a track like this on a Nickelback album would’ve been a well-received change in energy, however, in the big 2026, this just feels half-assed and confused. It’s nothing more than a song to try and prove a point, yet the point was so widely missed it’s unclear what it actually was.
Bones For The Crows immediately swoops in to save the catastrophe caused by the opener. The atmosphere that you’re immediately launched into within the first 30 seconds is nothing short of cinematic, and a true testament to what makes Nickelback spectacular. When they channel their raw passion and hone in on the sound that they’re known for, they truly do live up to the reason why they’re still loved by many. Chad’s vocals sound immaculate the entire way, and that only amplifies the feeling of being transported back to their 2005 release, “All the Right Reasons.” aided by the melodic guitar work and strings working harmoniously together. You can go ahead and forget about the original opening track, because this is the true start of “Everything Under The Sun”.
Following the same formula and goal of Bones For The Crows, track 4, Leave Me Behind is yet another rendition of the best parts of Nickelback, and honestly, an entire album of what makes these 2 tracks so nostalgic would’ve been a faultless release. Their ability to paint a resonating image with nothing but simple instrumentals and powerful vocals is where this band really does excel, and this is where they should’ve focused their energy this far in their career.
For fans of “Dark Horse”, you’ll want to pay attention to Chasin’ Famous, and Lift Somebody Up. Both have perfectly encapsulated the confident energy that can be found on Nickelback’s 2008 album. They’re bouncy, they’re catchy, they’re musically tight. If Chasin’ Famous wasn’t placed in the middle of the record, then it would’ve hit a drawn out lull, but instead, its placement saves “Everything Under The Sun” from losing a lot of potential listeners at the half-way point. All tracks that come after Bones For The Crows seem to disappear into obsoletion when you’re aware of what’s just round the corner with Chasin’ Famous, and the same happens again until you reach Lift Somebody Up. Having such a drop in excitement throughout most of the record causes a disconnect that’s hard to ignore, and cements this album as one that you’ll probably only listen to a few songs, while forgetting the rest even exist.
Simple Song is aptly named and speaks for itself. It does nothing to break boundaries or reinvent the wheel. It’s just there. There’s no desire to replay the track before it finishes, and it wouldn’t be surprising if this becomes the least played song on the album as it exposes itself as a filler track, yet it does nothing to fill in the cracks that are so obvious throughout the record. Technicolour Steamboat, and closing track, Last Night Was Fun are attempts to push this album towards a new audience with their abundance of over-processed vocals - found widely in Octanecore - but on a Nickelback album, they feel annoyingly adamant and gimmicky. For those whose birth year starts with a 2, you’ll eat this up, but for us 90’s kids, it’s a painful disappointment to see a once respected band turn into a marketing puppet, aiming for short form content exposure.
“Everything Under The Sun” isn’t a ground-breaking return to a career that spans 30 years. Instead, it’s fleeting teasers mixed in with a very clear message of, “We’ve changed.” Throughout the record, we’re offered glimpses of what once was, and these are the parts that will be received positively; their choices to switch between weighted guitar work and delicate acoustics, and their ability to strip it back to replicate their early sound carry the entire album, but it’s just not enough to take it across the finish line when it barely made it off the bat. There are fragmented pieces of greatness, where nostalgia carries the flame, yet they’re blown out by all of the other parts that are an attempt to be something they’re not. When “Everything Under The Sun” is good, it’s really fucking good as it serves as a reminder that even this far into your career, you never truly forget what started it all, but this is a sore case of the negatives far outweighing the positives, leaving little to no room for recurring visitation.
FFO: Theory of a Deadman, Three Days Grace, Daughtry
SCORE: 2/10
Everything Under The Sun is out on all streaming platforms now, released via Virgin Music Group.
Instagram | Apple Music | Spotify

